Connect with us

Politics

If Trump lawyer Cohen recorded conversations, is that OK?

Published

on

ABC News also reported that agents had seized recordings made by Cohen. NBC has not confirmed the reports.

As long as Cohen obtained advance permission from everyone involved, including the president, there is no real legal or ethical problem with recording phone calls or in-person conversations. If he did not obtain permission, it may still be legal in New York, so long as Cohen was a participant in the conversation.

In New York, a person is guilty of eavesdropping, a felony, when he or she unlawfully engages in wiretapping, “mechanical overhearing” of a conversation or intercepting an electronic communication.

Wiretapping is the use of a device to intentionally, and without consent, record a telephonic communication, by a person other than a participant. “Mechanical overhearing of a conversation” is slightly different: It is the intentional, non-consensual recording of any conversation, by a person not present at the conversation, by means of any device.

There’s no evidence so far that Cohen violated New York’s eavesdropping laws if he only possessed recordings of phone calls or conversations. First, New York is a “one-party” consent state: As long as one party to the conversation (in this case, Cohen) consents to the recording, the recording is lawful. Plus, there’s no evidence that these recordings were of conversations to which Cohen was not himself a participant.

As long as he was a participant on the call or present for the conversation, New York’s criminal eavesdropping statute does not apply to him. The state’s criminal statutes primarily target situations where third parties, hidden in a van on a street, for instance, or having placed a bug someone’s phone or smoke detector, secretly listen in on conversations.

As a “one-party” jurisdiction, New York is in the majority of states: As long as one party consents to the recording of a conversation, the recording is not criminal. Only a dozen states require the consent of all parties to a conversation for it to be recorded, including Connecticut and Pennsylvania. If Cohen surreptitiously recorded his conversations in one of those “all-party” consent states, then he might have violated that state’s law.

Surprising as it may seem, as long as all the participants are in New York, an lawyer who secretly records his own conversations or phone calls generally does not commit a crime.

However, even if not a crime, Cohen may have committed ethical violations as an attorney if he made recordings of his conversations without disclosing that he was doing so.

Historically, the Bar has expressed an aversion to secret tapings, which “offend the traditional high standards of fairness and candor that should characterize the practice of law.” The New York Rules of Professional Conduct for attorneys generally prohibit “conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation.”

Over time, this prohibition has been relaxed somewhat. In 2003, a New York City Bar Association Ethics Committee Opinion concluded that a lawyer may secretly tape a conversation if the lawyer has a reasonable basis for believing that disclosing the fact of the taping would significantly impair some societal good. However, the opinion adds that undisclosed taping is ethically impermissible when used as a routine practice.

If Cohen made it a practice to secretly tape conversations, it’s likely he violated ethical rules. The rules of professional responsibility appear to require a very good reason to justify the general prohibition against recording conversations without consent.

Danny Cevallos is an MSNBC legal analyst. Follow @CevallosLaw on Twitter.



Source link

Politics

Starmer wins huge victory as Labour leadership rules changed to avoid Corbynite takeover

Published

on

SIR KEIR STARMER has won a fight with the Labour-Left to change the party’s leadership rules to make it harder to for another Corbynite to be elected.

Source link

Continue Reading

Politics

Brexit Remoaning crushed as Shapps says UK exit has HELPED sort HGV driver shortage

Published

on

BREXIT doom-mongering from Remonaers has been blown apart after Grant Shapps claimed the UK’s departure from the European Union has helped the country push faster to sort the HGV driver shortage crisis.

Source link

Continue Reading

Politics

'It's our destiny!' Adonis outlines 'step by step plan' to reverse Brexit and rejoin EU

Published

on

LORD ADONIS outlined his “step by step” plan for take Britain back into the EU as he addressed Labour members in Brighton.

Source link

Continue Reading

Trending